Monday, March 03, 2008

Call me cynical and bitter...

So yes, it is still International Sex Workers Rights Day. At this moment, in places like NYC and NC, sex workers are gathering, face-to-face, talking and sharing and telling, planning and discussing. I would’ve liked to be there, but I have to buy windows…

And, yes, I will say now, I am feeling somewhat surly, but in a way, this does lead in nicely to something that I mentioned blogging about in Odds & Ends…that thing being…

No one can tell you what you can and cannot do. We all have things we support more ardently than others, and no one is telling you that you cannot support those things...

I guess it’s time to expand on that a bit. Well, it’s true. We all have things which are our main causes. It is not to say we do not find other issues to be of import, or realize how often various issues are entwined, but we all have our main concerns. We pick our battles, as it were. Race. Class. Disability Rights. Labor rights. Politics. Peace. Homosexual Issues. Trans Issues. Sexuality. Reproductive Choice. Religion. Sexism. Animal rights. We all have our thing. Often, these things blend; often these things are touched on in larger concerns of feminism, perhaps humanism, itself.

But I’d be lying if I said I hadn’t noted something today. And I don’t much feel like lying.

Apparently, while I don’t expect Sex Workers Rights to rank real high at all on everyone’s radars…it doesn’t seem to rank much at all on anyone’s.

“The Big Feminist Blogs”? One, Feministe, mentioned today at all. That’s it, one. Elsewhere out and about? Other than a few places like Amber’s, SITPS, and Sex Workers blogs, and a few shout outs, I see nothing. Nada. Zip. Zero. And I’ve looked. I’ve looked on big blogs and small, radical and sex positive, PoC and white, labor rights concerned and sexual freedom concerned. I’ve searched high and low.

And there’s not much. At all. Nary you mind that the way things are currently, however many sex workers could get robbed and raped tonight and have it laughed off by the law, nary you mind that sex workers pulled over by the law will be black mailed into favors, nary you mind that sex workers of all races, genders, classes, political bent, religion, will still be seen by the majority of humanity as less than human themselves, nary you mind possession of condoms in the highly vaunted Swedish State is cause for arrest and possible immediate deportation. Nary you mind. It doesn’t rate. It doesn’t rate a post, a line, a shout out, even a mention that today is International Sex Workers Rights day and a link to places like UBUNTU, HIPS, SWOP, PONY or ISWFACE. Nary you mind. Sex Work? Hell, I thought it was a feminist issue. Apparently not. Clinton and Obama and McCain, JVal, teenagers getting pedicures, sexist women reporters. Well, I voted for Obama, but yeah...

And sure, I don’t expect something like International Sex Workers Rights Day to rate even a footnote in various circles. I mean hell, if you are for abolition; you are, by default, against sex workers rights (what, with all that normalization and everything). I can also understand that other people’s issues are of high import right now and consume a lot of time and energy.

Yet still, I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t a little disappointed, and I don’t much feel like lying today.

If you don’t really intend to be an ally and speak up and out…don’t call yourself one. Don’t use us when it’s convenient and forget us when it’s important. Easier for all of us in the long run.

17 comments:

Amber said...

I noticed the same thing.

I just wish I'd had time to write more than what I did (which was basically just a huge quote from you!) but it was a busy, frankly shitty day, so... yeah. Didn't get time. But wanted to.

I will say, though (and Rusty and I were talking about this on the way to work this morning), that International Sex Workers Rights Day was far less publicized than the International Day to End Violence Against Sex Workers. I only heard of it myself a few weeks ago. By "publicized," of course, I'm not referring to mainstream media or anything; they wouldn't touch these issues with a ten-foot brass pole. I mean on blogs, listservs, etc.

Renegade Evolution said...

Amber: True, it was not as widely publicized, but, let us ponder WHY that is...

EVERYONE (even those who by default do not support sex workers RIGHTS) is against violence, towards anyone, even sex workers. Violence is, default, bad. People speak out against violence of any sort: the war, race motivated, class motivated, sexual orientation motivated, because we recgonize that violence, against anyone, is not a good thing. Being against violence is popular.

However, advocating for the rights of a marginalized group? Well, that gets a bit more dicey now, doesn't it? Yet still, you see it a lot. Many people support "rights" for various folk; the rights for gay marriage, the rights for underprivileged people to get quality educations, a woman's right to domain over her own body...

All good things, all things I support and care about...

But Sex Workers Rights? Hummm, for some folk, I think that is a tough one, or alien, or something they are afraid to talk about. But until they do, we get to stay subhuman.

Amber said...

You are 100% right.

Renegade Evolution said...

Amber:

100% is a lot....

maybe, heh, 90%.... (rimshot!)

Amber said...

Heh heh... nice! ;)

Tess Madrone said...

Let's remember too that there are many sex workers like me that live in places like SF where there was activism going on, but for some of us that isn't the best way to lend a hand. For me it has absolutely nothing to do with politics of what I believe,and everything to do with understanding from previous activist experience what my body and mind can handle. Believe me when I say women like Carol Leigh inspire me here very much, but I have to do it the way that works for me. That is on a more calm day to day level. I realize this may never change laws, but it does work to dispel stereotypes. Some people could call me naive, or catering to only the "happy" parts of sex, but for me I need to find a balance between taking care of me, having integrity in all that I do, and connecting with others. Despite all that said, I felt guilty I made no direct mention of it on my blog; it was a conscious decision that implies nothing more than I am connecting and trying to reach out in the ways I can.

Amber said...

Tess, I feel the same way you do. I've said before (on my blog and elsewhere) that I am not cut out to be a "front lines" activist. Some people are good at that sort of thing. I'm not. I don't have a thick skin, I don't deal well with conflict, and hardcore activism (rallies, protests, etc.) drains me emotionally and physically. So I prefer to write, and to interact with people on a smaller scale to help them see new perspectives.

All of this stuff helps. Don't ever doubt that.

Daisy said...

Hey, I mentioned you in my primary eve roundup! Granted, you got mentioned with Hillary and Christians, but didn't figure you'd mind that! :D

I'm just a lil ole blog though. My "Is Obama is the antichrist?" is getting more hits than I've had in a month, which is kinda scary, no?

Anonymous said...

I'm writing this because I want to help in whatever small way I can. I'm not a sex worker, I've never had contact with any, but I am a working man whose grandfather was a labor organizer. My life is touch-and-go a lot of weeks, but compared to sex workers... Well, everything I've seen suggests that's like comparing the labor movement from the 1970s to that of the 1870s, respectively.

Talking is all fine and good, but talking doesn't always get the job done. So...I want to know if there is any substantive way I can help.

Renegade Evolution said...

Anonymous: A few posts down you will see contact information for various sex workers rights organizations. I am sure any one of them would be happy to have assistance. Perhaps one is local for you?

Daisy Bond said...

I noticed this, too.

What was going through my head -- which isn't an excuse for not doing more, but might have happened to other self-proclaimed allies, too -- is something that I've noticed happens sometimes when I'm reading about the issues of a group I consider myself an ally to (i.e. POC issues). I want to call attention to them and talk about them, but I'm also uncertain about whether my voice (as an outsider, and a privileged one at that) is a valuable contribution to the mix. It's probably worth it to take the risk of sounding like an asshole to be a full participant, but I often do the easier thing and just point to what someone else is saying.

belledame222 said...

sorry, would have said something, i'm sort of running around and haven't had much time to update the blog. i may put up something day late and dollar short.

Stacey said...

Yeah, to be honest, I didn't personally do anything to promote March 3rd on the web beyond my own circle of contacts. Our local group opted for an informal private gathering and it was fantastic.

I agree with Tess, public action isn't for everybody. I find that I go back and forth on it, but really, I think December 17th is about the only public action that I can get enthusiastic about participating in each year- for all the reasons that Ren describes- it's an issue that people will support.

But talk to the public about sex workers rights? OMG, when I volunteered for the Measure Q campaign in Berkeley people were SO MEAN. In fucking Berkeley of all places! People were mean and verbally abusive because of SEX!

One day a woman circled the block in her car 3 times just to scream "You bitches...you..you whores!!" And the expression on her face was so angry and hateful! She could barely get the words out of her mouth. That was devastating to me. And that's just one example.

But I love seeing rallies and parades and I'm so happy that there are people with the enthusiasm and creativity to continue doing public actions. I participate when I feel moved to, but mostly I enjoy just watching. I attended for part of the action in SF last summer and it was really fun to watch!

I think there was a lot of visibility about the International Sex Workers Rights Day, but not a lot of clear ways about how to contribute/participate.

There was an emphasis on local organizing and less of a national call to action ie: Annie Sprinkle's 10 Things to do for Day to End Violence (which includes things you can do alone, in private, in public or with others.)

We also didn't have any kind of cool logo that folks could cut and paste loud and proud at the front of their blogs. Now THAT is a really solid way that our allies in tech-land who want to contribute could help us out. When we have an event that warrants re-posting to other blogs, creating a button for us to post would be great- since anonymous asked...

And there are a million other little tech things that we need from time to time- and our Tech Mistresses are over-worked. ;-)

andi said...

I wish I would have known. I would have made it point to write about it - as little as I know about the subject one more voice could not have hurt. Could it have?

cybersolidaires said...

Maybe you'll like to hear about this.

I've posted this today in the feminist blog I've been maintaining in Quebec since 2001: Sex Workers Call for Local Change on Global Rights Day
http://cybersolidaires.typepad.com/ameriques/2009/03/sex-workers-call-for-local-change.html

You'll also find a lot of content about sex worker's rights, mostly in French: http://cybersolidaires.typepad.com/ameriques/travaildusexe.html

We're not many feminists out there showing openly our support of the sex worker's fights, some of us are there. In Canada, there is also FIRST (Feminists Advocating for Rights and Equality for Sex Workers): http://www.firstadvocates.org (their listserv is busier then their web site).

In cybersolidarity

XXX

Nicole Nepton
http://www.cybersolidaires.org

Nicole Nepton said...

We're not many feminists out there showing openly our support of sex worker's fights, but some of us are there.

I've posted this today in the feminist blog I've been maintaining in Quebec since 2001:
Sex Workers Call for Local Change on Global Rights Day
http://cybersolidaires.typepad.com/ameriques/2009/03/sex-workers-call-for-local-change.html
You'll also find a lot of content about sex worker's rights, mostly in French: http://cybersolidaires.typepad.com/ameriques/travaildusexe.html

In Canada, there are Feminists Advocating for Rights and Equality for Sex Workers (FIRST): http://www.firstadvocates.org (their listserv is busier then their web site).

In cybersolidarity

Michael said...

Point taken Renegade, which is why we put out the Press Release which you can find on the link posted above by Cybersolidaires.

in solidarity
Michael
Stepping Stone