Tuesday, May 20, 2008

Allies

I’ll say it truthful and flat out, I have mixed feelings on allies. Part of this is on me, as I’m not notoriously good at trusting people or not speculating on their true motivations and intent. Part if it, however, is most certainly not on me, as some allies really seem to be anything but.

When I see people saying they are or want to be allies to sex workers / prostituted women, like Agent Mulder, I want to believe. I do. Hell, people in the sex biz, willingly or not, need allies. And sure enough, there are some damn good allies out there. A lot of the folk I consider to be the real deal are sex workers, or former sex workers themselves; folks like Jill B, so on, but this is not always the case. There are plenty of people who are not or have never been sex workers who I also consider to be allies- Elizabeth Wood and Amber come to mind. But then I look around and I see a lot of so-called allies who, well frankly, not really the kind of help sex workers and/or prostituted women need.

Some of ‘em are big names; Farley and Jensen come to mind. These people are not fucking allies. They are goddamn academics pushing their personal feelings and books and careers up on the backs of the people in the sex industry while ignoring those who do not agree with or challenge them. This is not the behavior of an ally. Point blank, end of story.

Some of them aren’t big names. There are writers, bloggers, so on, out there who like to say or think they are allies, but they aren’t. Being an ally has some guidelines, after all. I mean, let us look at this logically and such:

-If you support anything that might endanger the health of a sex worker, you are not an ally.
-If you support anything which might affect the legal standing, legal rights, and legal recourses of a sex worker, you are not an ally.
-If you actively seek to silence the words of sex workers, you are not an ally.
-If you advocate anything that impedes progress for sex workers rights, you are not an ally.
-If you support anything that keeps sex workers engaging in business in unsafe, criminalized, unregulated conditions, you are not an ally.
-If you infringe upon or disrupt a sex worker’s ability to earn a living, you are not an ally.
-If you patronize, mock, insult, judge, presume to speak for, speak over, lie about, threaten, slander, hack, make assumptions about, or belittle sex workers, you are not an ally.
-If you refuse to alter your terminology to suit terms sex workers prefer, you are not an ally.
-If you refuse to recognize sex work extends beyond street prostitution, you are not an ally.
-If you refuse to recognize the humanity of sex workers, you are not an ally.
-If you refuse to recognize many sex works are adults with a level of autonomy, you are not an ally.
-If you refuse to recognize that many people in sex work would choose other options if they were available, you are not an ally.
-If you actually do nothing to help sex workers in the here and now, you are not an ally.
-If you take on a savior, superior attitude towards sex workers, you are not an ally.
-If you use sex workers words, images, ideas, writings, or experiences without their consent or knowledge, you are not an ally.
-If you use sex workers to further your wider agenda or goal without their consent, you are not an ally.

Got it? Hey, you might pass the “you’re not a feminist if” tests, but if you fail here, you are no fucking ally to sex workers.

Supporting legislation that keeps sex work illegal and keeps sex workers from having legal rights and recourse? Supporting programs such as the No Prostitution Pledge which denies sex workers access to funding, medical care, condoms, education, and other options? Protesting at/ disrupting sex worker events, porn stores, strip clubs, adult industry gatherings? Harassing sex workers and dehumanizing them? Not the actions of allies.

So yes, a lot of the allies out there need to think about it. An occasional post when a hooker gets killed, a porn star commits suicide, or a stripper gets raped? That does not make you an ally. It makes you a fucking opportunist maximizing your creds on the bodies and bullshit faced by those in sex work every day…shit that social stigma and criminal status allow. Shit that some of these so-called allies support. Guess what?

With allies like that?

So if you’re not an ally…don’t pretend that you are. Call yourself whatever the hell you want- but ally? Not a word you're entitled to.

16 comments:

KH said...

Thank you. Enough with the third-rate academics & self-flattering activists, the pity & contempt, the lame ‘expertise’ that amounts to nothing, the paternalism. These people have good reason to fear & mistrust actual sex workers, because actual sex workers can see straight through them. They threaten their professional standing.

jerry said...

Not that it matters, but by your list I would consider myself an ally. I will ask "what about teh johnz?!"

I've seen various people who would seem to call themselves allies making statements along the line that being a sex worker should be legal, but being a john should not be? (That may fall into your "don't impede the work" requirement.)

Sorry to make this all about teh johnz! :)

Renegade Evolution said...

what about the johns is an...okay...question. Yes, it fringes on impeding...but I was thinking more along the lines of the brave warriors who picket strip bars and scream at the people going into them...that absolutely affects the take home pay of the women working there.

Amber said...

*standing ovation*

You knocked it out of the ballpark, again.

So, do I have your consent to repost your (awesome, spot-on, very helpful) list? :)

Renegade Evolution said...

Amber: The god emperor of rome approves you request.

Matt47 said...

As a fellow john who has recently been spending time with a lovely escort on several occasions, I hope I am doing my part as an ally in listening to her, hearing all her hopes & dreams, highs & lows, treating her with absolute respect and also pointing her in the direction of advice and support found on sexwork101.com, beingamberrhea.com and this very site - I would like to be an ally as much as possible...

Daran said...

I pass all of your tests, except this one:

-If you actually do nothing to help sex workers in the here and now, you are not an ally.

I don't consider myself obliged to actively assist every cause I support, (and don't have the personal resources to do so anyway). So count me as a supporter, but not an ally.

Octogalore said...

Good list. And yes, a lot of opportunists out there.

Just speaking for myself, I never saw customers as true allies when I was stripping. I felt that their desire to "get" me and to offer "support" often was directly connected to self interest and had very little to do with caring about sex workers generally.

I usually felt that the attractiveness of ally status had to do with the fact that the sex worker chosen to "ally" with really didn't need their "help."

Often my customer/"allies" would offer advice that I would appear grateful for, like telling me about various websites (which I typically already knew about) or suggesting various alternative careers (which were usually less attractive than the alternative careers that I'd already had and left). I'm sure they were convinced they were doing a real service. Sadly, there are many sex workers who were more in need, and less likely to receive "help" from these cusomter/"allies."

Anthony Kennerson said...

The way I see it, if someone who attempts to call himself an "ally" of sex workers does not completely and totally respect their lives and profession, and does not totally commit themselves to defending their choices, then they don't get to call themselves "allies".

On the other hand, it is very much possible to be a true ally of sex workers without resorting to shouting it through the rooftops at every opportunity.

Or, as the popular saying goes: "Don't sing it....bring it." Action speaks louder than words, you know.

Requesting permission as well to copy that fine list at my blog, Commander Henchwoman...


Anthony

Renegade Evolution said...

granted

Philomela said...

Ren This post really made me think about a lot of stuff, I'd really like to copy some of it and link to it in a post I want to make.

I'll understand if you say no to this bearing in mind you might not want the people who read my blog to come through to here,

Also If you want I can send you the post before I post it, so you can see if you are okay with the way I'm using it.

Daisy said...

This posts rocks!!!!!

Iamcuriousblue said...

Well, speaking for myself, I'm not going to be pretentious enough to deem myself an ally of anybody. However, I see sex workers as people I do feel some kind of reciprocity and gratitude toward, being on the consumer end of the sex industry. I feel that way in general about people who's products and services I consume, or people who I choose to interact with.

Its the same reason I don't feel any sense of accountably to feminists on the other side of the debate, in spite of their claims that I should – I just don't see them as people I even want to have anything to do with (I only wish it was possible to not even belong to the same society as these people) or want anything from other than to be left alone.

Renegade Evolution said...

Daisy- Thanks

Philo- go ahead.

SnowdropExplodes said...

I tend to see the term "ally" in terms of "the success of my cause is somehow directly linked to the success of yours", and for me personally, I don't have that kind of link with sex workers, so - I don't call myself an ally.

The trouble with radical feminist anti-sex work types is that they seem to see the success of their cause as not linked to anyone else's; people are either "in the way" or "not in the way" of their success. Sex workers who are victims are "not in the way"; sex workers who are not victims are "in the way".

I do what little I can to support sex workers' rights and causes, but that's because in my philosophy, sex workers are human beings, "born free, and equal in dignity and rights" which isn't a sex worker-specific idea at all; it's just that sex workers are, in Western society, often among the ones most often denied that dignity and those rights. Not by the nature of their work, but by the nature of the law's reaction to them, and by the nature of the reaction to them from many segments of society.

The most I've done to help sex workers "in the here and now" is write to my MP in favour of the decriminalising of sex work.

Infra said...

This is probably a clueless question, but a tangent off of the terminology point: do PSOs come under the category of sex workers?

I'd be inclined to think that they do (since the work is an interactive sexual service), but I'd also be inclined to think that some people would consider that stance to be trivializing (since the job doesn't actually involve the body, in any way other than speaking).