Tuesday, July 22, 2008

What about the men...

“Men” in this instance meaning male sex workers, like those in Chicago at DA:PBS, like that fellow standing there with me, a guy who goes by the name Jack. Jack was one of the first people I met up there in Chicago. Wednesday evening, after I got to the hotel and had a late dinner with Amber and Dacia, I ran into Jack, Serpent, V*, Tara & R*, and the group of us went to my new favorite hole in the wall neighborhood bar in the world, the L&L Tavern, where we had a drink, all got to know each other, so on. Later on, the other folk departed, and Jack and I decided to head down to an after hours club, where we hung out, talked about life, sex work, and all kinds of stuff. You know, it was a lot like what other people do, chat work, relationships, cool people and places, experiences, observations…things people talk about, we just happened to be in a unique line of work. We also both, self-admittedly and everything, generally love our jobs, even with the bad stuff. I liked Jack a lot. Friendly, smart, witty, cultured and pleasantly devious, generally a whole lot of fun to hang out with.

But as time went on in Chicago, something became apparent to me. Like me, in sex work, Jack has some privilege. He’s white and conventionally attractive. He has other skills and talents. He has a roof over his head. And, as I learned in talking and listening to other male sex workers, Jack has other advantages as well it seems. Now I’m pretty short, but I think you can tell that while thin, Jack isn’t a small guy. He comes across in ways probably deemed much more traditionally or conventionally masculine than many other male sex workers. And sure enough, Jack says he’s never really had a whole lot of strife or violence in the course of his job…and sure enough, I believe him.

But in listening to some of the other fellows there, also sure enough, the experiences of the men at the event were just as diverse as anyone else’s. Some of the men there presented on a panel about men in sex work, and it was interesting to hear the similarities and the differences; they are subject to violence, rape, harassment, outing, discrimination and all those good things just like the gals, but often times, they suffer the (presumed obvious) double stigma of being homosexual, they usually make less money for their work, it’s often assumed that no men are forced or coerced into sex work, and when they get hurt, robbed, raped…well, they really take it in the chops then. Male sex workers? Some people don’t think men can be raped at all. Some people don’t think sex workers can be raped at all. Even more people do not think male sex workers can be raped at all. When they do report it, they get asked why didn’t they fight back? The get told they should’ve just stood up for themselves, or that they should’ve taken it like a man. They get told to suck it up. They get laughed at, and yep, like their female counterparts, they get told they deserved it. And unlike their female counterparts, male sex workers? When it comes to safe spaces and resources and crisis centers and such? They pretty much have nothing at all.

And, as they brought up in their panel, the men aren’t even all that included in sex worker outreach organizations. Even there they are marginalized. Our logos? Geared towards women. Our terminology? Geared towards women. Our “public faces”? Mostly women. When people think of men and sex work, they think of clients, johns, pimps, pornographers. They don’t think of male strippers, or escorts, hustlers or performers. They think of customers, and not those providing the services. They think of victimizers, not victims. Studies done on sex workers? Men are rarely, if ever, considered. Media concern? Also rarely aimed their way. Funding? Nope, they don’t see much of that either. I mean sure, all sex workers tend to be pushed into the shadows, but the men? From the of age guys who choose to do it to pick up some quick cash to the young boys involved in forced sexual labor as a part of the sex tourism trade? These males? They really are often left in the dark.

I’ve written about men and sex work before, as has Ernest wrt to porn, and I’ve generally tried to be inclusive in my language, but after listening to the men in Chicago, I’ve realized that really isn’t good enough. The men in sex work? They face the same shit as us, and a whole raft of their own. So yeah, for starters, I’d like to ask everyone, when writing about sex work…remember “what about the men?”, and not just the pimps, clients, johns and pornographers…but the sex workers too.

Because Jack there, Will over here, and every other one of those guys at the event, and the other guys in the biz they know? Well, they are just as real as any one of the women in the biz…and they deserve some consideration.

*in these posts, if I’ve not asked for permission to use peoples names, I will be using letter designations.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hello there, wonderful blog you have and I think this is something that really does need to be pointed out more often, I've read some research studies/reports etc and some of them do bring up this issue of a lack of support for male sex workers which may in some cases make them more vulnerable than women.
It's also definitely telling that whenever I've had a debate/argument about legalising and regulating sex work(unions and all that) it's always been assumed that only women do the actual dirty stuff.
Also I do love your blog for vindicating my dislike of the rad fems I've met, they just came off as puritans in drag to me, being a bloke didn't help me there tho :D.

LiaStarLight said...

Great post, Ren. That session at DA:PBS really touched me.

Thanks for doing whatcha' do!

Isobel said...

I've often wondered about this issue. Activists cry unto the heavens about the victimized women in the porn trade but no one really seems to give two shits for the men in the trade. It's always irked me, that double-standard. But most of feminism's double standards chafe me. You can't have it both ways. Care about both "victimized" genders or leave everyone alone and let them work. Just because someone has a penis doesn't mean that he isn't a victim when it comes to forceful sex. Men deserve the same rights and resources as women. I find it terribly sad that this is even something that should even have to be mentioned. If it was the other way around someone would have paid hell for it.

Amanda said...

Jack was a real sweetie. I didn't get to meet many of our brothers, but as with our sisters -- I liked every one I met.

The panel made the point I've realized over the past year: we all have the same basic issues. There was too much division at the conference this year -- we all need to remember we're fighting for exactly the same things because we ALL face the same basic shit. Sometimes it's less obvious than other times, but every sex worker is in this together. To me, that's the most important thing to remember.

If we can all remember that and let it guide our actions, inclusiveness will naturally happen. (Yeah, I'm guilty of emphasizing the female experience because it's what I know.)

XX

PS: Oh, and it was SO GOOD to meet you finally.

Renegade Evolution said...

thanks y'all, and amanda, likewise!

itsnotmyfault said...

I tried to discuss male sexwork with my former classmates (when I took the separatist feminist class two years ago) and they all agreed that men cant be exploited like women (of course, they all meant that *all* female sex workers are treated badly and being exploited).

I have little experience with female sex workers, most of the people I know who are sex workers or used to be sex workers are FtM transgendered in various states of their transition. These were not men according to my classmates, they were butch women.

Im not sure where im going with this.. but I really appreciate your blog. While Im still writing, have you heard anything about the Swedish law against purchase of sexual services?

Daisy said...

He's so cute!

Just had to say that. I don't think he'll mind, will he? ;)

Aspasia said...

Yeah, Jack is gorgeous and I'm not ashamed to say I covet his locks. But Ren, you make a very good point, the movement does need to include male sex workers a lot more. I suppose since it is a female-dominated field, that's why most of the logos are aimed toward us. But I don't see why we can't have a male silhouette on some of the logos. A designer needs to get on that.

Anonymous said...

It is about time someone stands up for the men. It gets fucking annoying to see people thinking violence against women is so horrible, but violence against men is somehow okay. It is a ridiculous double standard.